● NEW PIZZA ORIGIN STORY EVERY SUNDAY  ·  ALL CLASSES FREE
JOINSUBSCRIBE ON YOUTUBE
NEW YORK CITY (PART 1)PIZZA ORIGIN STORIES · EP. 4THIN AND FOLDABLE

AMERICA'S
FIRST PIZZERIA?

For a century Lombardi's 1905 was 'America's first pizzeria' — until a researcher's dig through city directories turned up Filippo Milone and an 1894 shop on Mulberry Street, and the story got richer, not smaller.

WATCH ON YOUTUBESUBSCRIBESHORTS ↓
THE SHORT ANSWER
For a century Lombardi's 1905 was 'America's first pizzeria' — until a researcher's dig through city directories turned up Filippo Milone and an 1894 shop on Mulberry Street, and the story got richer, not smaller.

THE STORY IN BRIEF

Every great pizza origin story needs three things: a hero, a date, and a sign out front. New York has all three. The sign on Spring Street says America's first pizzeria. It turns out the oven is a little older than its hero.

Lombardi's on Spring Street is one of the most famous names in American pizza, and 1905 is the date everyone repeats. Then a Chicago researcher named Peter Regas went looking for the paperwork: ship manifests, city directories, Italian-language newspapers. We follow the trail from a 17-year-old Gennaro Lombardi stepping off the steamship Calabria in 1904, to a baker named Filippo Milone and a pizzaiolo named Giovanni Santillo, to the shops that learned from them across the city.

WHAT'S PROVEN, WHAT'S LEGEND

LEGEND
The 1905 date, the "first license to sell pizza" and the wrapped-in-paper tomato pie are the traditional Lombardi's story. The license has never been found. We call it a legend.
DOCUMENTED
Documented by researcher Peter Regas: Gennaro Lombardi arrived on the S.S. Calabria in November 1904, age 17, listed as a laborer. Filippo Milone very likely established the pizzeria at 53 Spring Street around 1898, and Giovanni Santillo advertised "Antica Pizzeria Napoletana" there in August 1904. These are Regas's readings of ads and directories, which is why we say "very likely."
DOCUMENTED
Lombardi bought the shop in 1908, repurchased it around 1918, and owned it until he died in 1958. Totonno's opened in Coney Island in 1924 and Patsy's in East Harlem in 1933. That Patsy Lancieri learned at Lombardi's is reported, not confirmed.
DOCUMENTED
Regas believes Milone started the Bleecker Street pizzeria that later carried John Sasso's name. Milone died in 1924 with no children.
DOCUMENTED
Lombardi's original location closed in 1984 and reopened about ten years later a block away at 32 Spring Street.
DOCUMENTED
The people shown are illustrations, not photographs of the real individuals, and the maps are illustrative.

SHORTS FROM THIS STORY

MORE STORIES TO TASTE
ALL STORIES →
← ALTOONANEXT STORY: DETROIT, NOVEMBER 22, 2026
SLICE STORIES · THE NEWSLETTER
ONE EMAIL A WEEK. THE STORY BEHIND THE PIZZA.

One short email a week. Unsubscribe any time.