AMERICA'S
FIRST PIZZERIA?
For a century Lombardi's 1905 was 'America's first pizzeria' — until a researcher's dig through city directories turned up Filippo Milone and an 1894 shop on Mulberry Street, and the story got richer, not smaller.
THE STORY IN BRIEF
Every great pizza origin story needs three things: a hero, a date, and a sign out front. New York has all three. The sign on Spring Street says America's first pizzeria. It turns out the oven is a little older than its hero.
Lombardi's on Spring Street is one of the most famous names in American pizza, and 1905 is the date everyone repeats. Then a Chicago researcher named Peter Regas went looking for the paperwork: ship manifests, city directories, Italian-language newspapers. We follow the trail from a 17-year-old Gennaro Lombardi stepping off the steamship Calabria in 1904, to a baker named Filippo Milone and a pizzaiolo named Giovanni Santillo, to the shops that learned from them across the city.
WHAT'S PROVEN, WHAT'S LEGEND
CHAPTERS
SOURCES
- History.com, "Meet a Long-Lost Father of New York City Pizza"
- Wikipedia, Gennaro Lombardi
- Wikipedia, Lombardi's Pizza
- Wikipedia, Patsy's Pizzeria
- Peter Regas, "Who was Gennaro Lombardi?" (Pizza History Book)
- Peter Regas, "Who Established the Famous Pizzeria at 53 Spring Street?" (Pizza History Book)
- Peter Regas, Pizza History Book project page
- U.S. Pizza Museum, "Lost Forefathers of Pizza in America Discovered"
- Culinary Historians of Chicago, "Thoughts on the origins of pizzerias in America and Chicago"
Spot something we got wrong? Tell us in the comments. Locals always know best.
SHORTS FROM THIS STORY
ANOTHER GREAT ARGUMENT
ANOTHER GREAT ARGUMENT
ANOTHER GREAT ARGUMENT